Samebed Mattress Topper Review
Last Updated: September, 2024 | This Post May Contain Affiliate Links
There's totally no doubt about the luxurious feel and superior comfort of down goose and duck feather mattress toppers. However, not every sleeper can afford or handle down toppers. Some may be shopping on a tight budget, while others may be allergic to the material. If you fall into any of these categories, your best bet is to opt for a down alternative mattress topper. This material won't trigger allergic reactions and comes at a much more affordable price.
In this comprehensive review, we’ll cover our experience when taking the Samebed Down Alternative Mattress Topper through our 2-stage review process, going over its pros and cons, what it's made of, not to mention its performance and company policies to help you decide whether it's right for you.
Summary
The Samebed Down Alternative Mattress Topper strikes a perfect balance between cushioning and body support, thanks to its superior loft and luxury feel. A touch of bounce on the surface makes it easy to shift positions and move around on.
What We Like;
What We Don’t Like;
Samebed Mattress Topper Overview
Sometimes, sleeping cool is the only way to have a peaceful night experience. If you can relate to this, then you're looking for Samebed’s Cooling Mattress Protector. With microfiber fabric and snow down alternative filling throughout, you can rest on fluffy clouds while keeping heat and sweat at bay.
Its double border pillow top design keeps the filling in place to prevent deformation. Since the filling is soft, breathable, and quiet, you can shuffle and shift positions without worrying about waking up your partner. Plus, the extra thick layer of plush comfort will help alleviate strain around your shoulders, neck, and lower back.
You can securely fit this mattress topper over a mattress 21 inches deep, thanks to its extended bed skirt design. And with the 360° all-around wrapping construction, you can toss and turn freely during those sleepy nights without feeling the topper shuffling or slipping off when you get up. Another great thing about the Samebed Down Alternative Mattress Topper is that it’s machine-washable, so you can toss it in your washing machine on a gentle cycle and sun-dry or tumble-dry it.
Materials and Construction
This Extra Thick Mattress Pad Cover is an all-time favorite with top-quality and durability fitted to its price. It features a snow down alternative fill and a microfiber shell for a more luxurious night's sleep. The Samebed Mattress Topper is designed to cradle all sleep positions while still offering pressure point relief around the back, neck, and shoulders - all crucial parts in need of support when sleeping.
Since the construction material is naturally breathable, it regulates temperature perfectly, ensuring you never wake up shivering or drenched in sweat. The topper features a unique box-quilted design to keep the down alternative filling locked in place, while a stretchable knitted skirt keeps the entire topper from falling off the mattress.
The Samebed Down Alternative Mattress Topper is available in 3 color options and 7 sizes: California king, king, queen, full XL, full, twin XL, twin. We tested the queen-size white model for this review.
Samebed Mattress Topper Firmness and Feel
For sleepers who want to change the firmness and feel of their sleep surface, adding a down alternative mattress topper is one of the most common and cost-effective ways of doing so. It's worth noting that the firmness level of your mattress can change depending on your height and body weight.
But overall, the Samebed Mattress Topper delivered a luxuriously soft sleep experience when I tested it. It also had a bouncy and responsive feel. I didn't sink into the surface, and I still got good support and body cushioning while sleeping on it. And since it's more responsive, compared to gel memory foam mattress toppers, such as the Nolah Mattress Topper, I was able to move around on it quite easily.
How Does the Samebed Down Alternative Mattress Topper Feel on Different Mattresses?
Now, let's discuss what the Samebed Down Alternative Mattress Topper feels like on beds of different firmness levels.
Firm Mattress
Adding the Samebed Down Alternative Mattress Topper onto a firmer mattress gives it a cozy, fluffy, medium-firm feel. As an extra thick mattress topper, the Samebed topper gave me enough room to sink into the surface for some nice body contouring.
However, the firm bed under the soft mattress topper still offered support where I needed the most. I think this combination would work best for back sleepers and individuals suffering from back pain.
Medium Firm Mattress
I think adding this mattress topper to a medium-firm mattress will make it deliver more pressure relief and body contouring without compromising on the bed's overall stability. This would be a perfect option for sleepers who want a cooling layer or those in need of just a little more body-contouring than their sleep surface currently offers.
Soft Mattress
If you have an already-soft mattress, I think adding a plush, cushioning mattress topper might actually give it an incredibly soft feel without making your sleep surface feel overly doughy. This might work well for strict side sleepers with severe shoulder or hip pain.
Samebed Down Alternative Mattress Topper Performance Ratings
Now, let's go over some performance factors like pressure relief, motion isolation, temperature regulation, and more. See below how the Samebed Down Alternative Mattress Topper performed in these categories.
Pressure Relief
All in all, the Samebed Down Alternative Mattress Topper has excellent pressure relief thanks to its down alternative fill, which offers a bouncy and responsive surface to help relieve pressure. This plush fill also conforms closely to the body to promote proper spinal alignment. However, it's worth noting that heavyweight sleepers might find that this topper doesn't provide enough pressure relief for comfort.
Motion Isolation
Motion isolation refers to how a mattress topper prevents the transfer of movement across the surface. Generally, a sleep surface with great motion isolation is perfect for couples and anyone who shares their bed with a pet, as they're less likely to feel movement on their side of the mattress.
Overall, I think the Samebed Mattress Topper prevented the transfer of motion quite well. When I slept with my partner, I didn't feel her movements during the night despite her being a combo sleeper. With a microfiber fabric and a 5D & 7D snow down alternative filling, this Extra Thick Mattress Pad Cover did an excellent task of absorbing vibrations.
Temperature Regulation
While two people usually overheat more easily than one, the Samebed Mattress Topper is designed to keep hot sleepers cooler, just like a latex foam or gel-infused memory foam mattress topper. Aside from adding softness to your mattress, the 400TC cotton cover is naturally breathable, which helps keep your mattress cool and sweat-free. Plus, the 5D & 7D snow down alternative fill promotes maximum airflow, delivering plush comfort without trapping body heat.
Edge Support
Edge support typically refers to how well the edge of your mattress topper can support your body weight. If your topper has sturdy edge support, you should feel just as supported when you sleep on the sides as you would in the center.
Sturdy edge support can make your sleep surface feel larger, giving you more sleeping space. I tested the Samebed's edge support by sleeping, sitting, and moving around on the edge of the topper. I found myself sinking through the snow down alternative fill, so I'd say the Samebed Mattress Topper doesn't have sturdy edge support.
Ease of Movement
The Samebed mattress topper's comfort system consists primarily of a breathable and skin-friendly fabric and a snow down alternative fill. Although these materials conform closely to the body, they regain their original shape more quickly than a traditional memory foam mattress topper.
This minimizes the chances of experiencing the “trapped in the mattress” feeling mostly associated with memory foam toppers. During testing, I was really impressed by how the Samebed Mattress Topper maintained its shape, just like latex mattress toppers, without hindering movement.
Different Sleep Positions on the Samebed Down Alternative Mattress Topper
I think the Samebed Down Alternative Mattress Topper is a solid choice for side sleepers weighing less than 230 pounds. When side sleeping, the down-like filling and microfiber fabric gave the surface a luxurious feel that helped cradle my shoulders, hip region, and joints. These materials also deliver a plush pillow top padding, which helps maintain proper spinal alignment.
Switching to my back, I felt quite comfortable here, too. As a lightweight sleeper, I think the Samebed Down Alternative Mattress Topper helped evenly distribute my weight and prevented aching around my lumbar region.
This played a crucial role in keeping me from bottoming out of the topper. However, I'd recommend heavyweight back sleepers opt for the best firm mattress topper that doesn't allow excessive sinkage for a good night's sleep.
Finally, moving on to my stomach, I found that the Samebed Mattress Topper was moderately comfortable and supportive. However, our numerous tests indicated that it lacked the perfect balance of body support and cushioning for stomach sleepers who weigh more than 130 pounds.
If you're a heavy-bodied person who enjoys stomach sleeping, I think you'll have a much easier time retaining neutral spinal alignment on a firmer mattress topper that can keep your midsection from sinking below your shoulders and lead to lower back pain over time.
Warranty, Shipping, and Return Policies
Here's what you should expect when you purchase the Samebed Snow Down Alternative Mattress Topper.
Availability
This cooling mattress topper is currently sold through online retailers. This means shoppers can't try it physically before making a purchase.
Shipping
The Samebed Down Alternative Mattress Topper ships within the contiguous U.S. Free in-home delivery is available in the United States. You can expect to receive your down alternative mattress topper within 3 - 5 business days after placing an order.
Trial
The Samebed Down Alternative Mattress Topper comes with a 30-night return policy that begins on the delivery day. During this timeframe, you can test your mattress topper and return it for a refund of the buying price.
Warranty
Most Amazon mattress pads and mattress protectors are usually backed by a 3-year warranty that covers flaws in materials and workmanship. This cover is only available to the original buyer of the topper. The topper must have been used appropriately and be free of abuse.
It's worth noting that Samebed offers a 365-day satisfaction guarantee for their snow down alternative mattress topper. So, if you're unsatisfied with your purchase or have any questions, feel free to contact Amazon’s customer service team directly for help.
Samebed Mattress Topper Comparison
If you've never used down alternative mattress toppers before, it's always wise to do some comparison shopping to understand what you're getting yourself into. Let's compare the Samebed Mattress Topper with 3 down alternative mattress toppers.
PlushBeds Down Mattress Topper
The PlushBeds Down Mattress Topper also gives you an opportunity to experience the soft, luxurious comfort feel of down toppers but without the drawbacks. Unlike the Samebed Mattress Topper, this topper features vegan down, a silky smooth material that provides a buoyant and fluffy texture.
Both the PlushBeds' and Samebed's toppers are excellent picks for hot sleepers, thanks to their breathable design and cooling materials. But one of the main differences between the two is the way they feel. PlushBeds’ vegan down gives it a more responsive feel, making it an excellent alternative for combo sleepers.
Side sleepers will also appreciate how the down alternative cushioning eases painful pressure points from sleeping on overly firm mattresses. Plus, the mattress topper stays cool and comfortable, thanks to the breathable cotton twill.
Other outstanding features of this high quality mattress topper from PlushBeds include:
- Down-like fill is hypoallergenic and helps wick away excess moisture
- Breathable cotton twill prevents heat buildup
- Baffle box stitching helps keep the fibers in place
Due to sanitary regulations, the PlushBeds Down Mattress Topper isn't returnable. However, it's backed by a 2-year warranty.
If you like that luxury hotel bed feel, the Helix Plush Mattress Topper is another ideal alternative for you. This mattress topper comes in a soft pillow top feel that provides a cloud-like sleep experience. Featuring 1.5 inches of fiberfill, this plush mattress topper from Helix is designed for cozy comfort.
Its state-of-the-art cluster fiber fill offers a classic luxury feel while still remaining resilient and delivering high loft balance. In addition to providing a plush, luxurious feel, the fiberfill promotes maximum airflow and reduces hot spots to keep you cool and comfortable as you sleep. What's more, it is wrapped in a thin and breathable hypoallergenic bamboo cover, making it an ideal option for hot sleepers, too.
Like the Samebed Down Alternative Mattress Topper, the Helix Plush Topper uses the baffle box stitching technique to create pockets to trap the fiberfill. This ensures that it's evenly distributed throughout the mattress topper and keeps it from shifting when you sleep at night.
Other notable features of the Helix Plush Mattress Topper include:
- Machine-washable, making it easy to clean and maintain
- Ultra-soft fibers are more resilient compared to cotton
- Revoloft Cluster fiberfill provides a cloud-like mattress feel
Unlike the Samebed Mattress Topper, this soft pad comes with a 100-night sleep trial period, which starts on the day of delivery. The company also backs their soft mattress toppers with a 1-year warranty.
Lucid Down Alternative Mattress Topper
Like the Samebed Mattress Topper, this topper from Lucid features an ultra-soft down alternative fill that can help you soften the feel of your firm mattress without the drawbacks of a down mattress topper. It boasts the classic slow-response memory foam mattress topper feel that helps contour to the unique curves of the body, leaving sleepers feeling cradled and hugged.
The down alternative fill is also designed to relieve common pressure points by evenly distributing weight across the sleep surface. While both mattress toppers are engineered to prevent heat retention, the Lucid Down Alternative Topper features a cotton percale cover that eliminates excess body heat from the sleep surface, keeping you from sleeping hot. What's more, its baffle box stitching helps improve breathability for a naturally cooling sleep. This makes it one of the best mattress toppers for hot sleepers.
Aside from offering an extra soft layer for back pain relief, other reasons why we think the Lucid Down Alternative Mattress Topper is a solid choice for shoppers on a budget include:
- Ultra-plush hypoallergenic down alternative fill delivers excellent motion isolation
- 100% cotton percale cover allows for maximum airflow
- Zoned design offers targeted body support
Lucid backs their down alternative mattress topper with a 30-night trial period. If you choose to keep your topper, you also receive a 3-year warranty against manufacturing defects.
Closing Thoughts
Overall, this down alternative mattress topper from Samebed is a solid choice for anyone who's in need of some cushioning and stress-relieving sleep. It will not only support you at night and make your mattress more comfortable, but you'll also get to experience the superior comfort of down without compromising on comfort for functionality.