Skip to content

Is a 4-inch Mattress Topper Too Much? 

Have you ever bought a mattress topper that left you feeling like it didn't make a difference in the softness or support of your mattress? This is often the case when you buy thinner mattress toppers. Mattress toppers vary in thicknesses, starting at around 1 inch, all the way up to 4 inches and sometimes more.

If you have a thin mattress that either isn't providing enough support, or needs to be softer, opting for a thicker mattress topper could be a good choice. These toppers are ideal for side sleepers and heavyweight sleepers as they provide more comfort for pressure points and help facilitate more restorative sleep.

However, these thicker mattress toppers aren't suited for all situations, and there's certain times where 4 inches may be too much.

Read on to learn more about how 4-inch mattress toppers affect sleep and what you need to consider before choosing the thickness of your mattress topper.

Mattress Topper Thickness Options

Mattress topper thickness usually varies between one and four inches. The thickness of your topper generally depends on the density of the filing, material, and size. That's why you may find some toppers exceeding the 4-inch thickness. 

Below, we'll look at each level of thickness and see how it can improve your sleep quality and which requirements it meets. 

1 to 2-Inch Mattress Toppers 

As the thinnest toppers on the market, one and two-inch mattress toppers are mostly used to add some plushness and cushion to an otherwise hard mattress. Some shoppers who buy 1 or 2-inch mattress toppers also use them on new mattresses to improve the softness and comfort of the sleep surface. 

It's worth noting that a 2-inch mattress topper doesn't provide pressure point support and isn't suitable for sleepers with significant back pain issues. What's more, it's not ideal for an older mattress because it doesn't offer a proper layer of thickness to help improve the performance of the otherwise sagging mattress. 

3-Inch Mattress Toppers

A 3-inch thick mattress topper offers a visible improvement in thickness, thanks to the one extra inch. It's firmer, thicker, and has more reliable support. Plus, there are many types of 3-inch mattress toppers, giving you a wide range of options as you begin your search for a new topper. 

You get to choose between a softer or a firmer topper to help you change the firmness level of your mattress. For a firmer feel, you can opt for a latex topper or a memory foam model with a firmer rating. And for a more plush feel, you can choose a wool topper or a memory foam topper with a soft rating. 

Overall, these toppers are an ideal alternative if you want to make your bed more comfortable or improve its pressure point support and overall performance. They can also help you customize your mattress if you aren't sure what mattress topper thickness you prefer. 

4-inch Mattress Toppers

4-inch mattress toppers are usually considered one of the thickest toppers on the market. They're the perfect combination of support, comfort, and the ability to cover the deficiencies in your old mattress. 

Four-inch toppers are used for older beds made of memory foam or have old spring coils. You can also use them on mattresses that have started to lose shape, causing pressure point issues and back pain. 

That said, if you're searching for a durable, supportive, and incredibly comfortable topper, the 4-inch models might be all you need. These toppers won't only offer a supportive layer for a more sound sleep but will also stay in shape for a much longer period. 

5-inch Mattress Toppers

Although these are rare, 5-inch mattress toppers are a thing. Many mattress-making companies include them in their offer as their thickest models. With a 5-inch mattress topper, you can transform any mattress into a brand-new unit. 

Irrespective of whether you're using these mattress toppers on a hybrid or memory foam bed, a new or an old, saggy mattress, they'll provide a layer of comfort and support for your entire body. 

5-inch toppers often come in medium-firm to firm versions and feature different layers of covers and materials to achieve this perfect thickness. 

What to Consider Before You Choose the Thickness of Your Mattress Topper

If you're still wondering whether a 4-inch mattress topper is too thick for your needs, we've got some guidelines to help you settle for the right thickness for your topper. 

Size of Your Mattress

Since mattress toppers are essentially an extra top layer to the mattress, they should perfectly line up with your mattress. For instance, if you have a queen size bed, you need a mattress topper that can match a queen mattress. Fortunately, toppers come in various proportions that can fit your specific mattress size, making choosing the right topper much easier. 

The Foam Density 

Generally, density is the measurement of a substance's mass divided by its volume. For instance, a bag with few clothes in it has a lower density than the same bag with more clothes. When it comes to mattress toppers, manufacturers usually determine foam density by measuring the object's weight per cubic foot. So, if you're getting a memory foam mattress topper, knowing its density will tell you how durable it is and how it can change the feel of your mattress. 

The Condition of Your Mattress

Before deciding on the thickness of your topper, you should also consider the current condition of your existing mattress. If you're using a new mattress, a two-inch mattress topper will give you the comfort and support you need. However, if your mattress is old and unreliable, you'll be fine buying a 4-inch topper. 

Sleeping Position and Body Weight 

To purchase a perfect mattress topper with the right thickness for your needs, always consider your sleeping position and body weight. 

Side Sleeping

For sleepers under 130 pounds, a 2-inch mattress topper will offer sufficient body support and comfort. For sleepers over 130 to 230 pounds, we recommend mattress toppers between 2 and 3 inches thick. And if you weigh over 230 pounds, you should opt for a 4-inch mattress topper.

Back Sleeping

If you're a back sleeper, you want a topper that will support you without sagging. Ideally, you need one that will support your lower, middle, and upper back with the right balance to curve to your spine. If you weigh less than 130 pounds, a 2-inch mattress topper may give your back the support it needs. For sleepers between 130 and 230 pounds, as well as over 230 pounds, we recommend mattress toppers of 3 to 4 inches. 

Stomach Sleeping

Out of all the sleep positions, stomach sleepers should go for the firmest mattress topper. Stomach sleeping adds pressure on the lower back, especially if you lack the proper body support. For stomach sleepers under 130 pounds, 2-inch mattress toppers might be the best option. If you weigh between 130 and 230 pounds or over 230 pounds, you want to go for a 4-inch mattress topper. 


Another factor to consider when choosing the right thickness option for your topper is purpose. For instance, if you're looking for the best mattress topper for pain relief, a much thicker topper might actually worsen the condition. Similarly, a firm mattress topper for lower back pain must balance body weight and thickness. 

How to Choose the Right Topper

Aside from thickness, here are other vital things to consider before buying a mattress topper. 


Mattress topper prices usually range from $100 to $500, depending on the topper size, manufacturer, and type of mattress topper.

Note: A higher price tag doesn't necessarily mean that you're buying a top-quality mattress topper.

Some high-end toppers include feathers, latex, and wool toppers. For a more budget-friendly alternative, check out cotton, polyester, or memory foam mattress toppers. 

Specific Medical Conditions 

Persons with certain medical conditions like back pain may need firm mattress toppers with thin comfort layers. Toppers in the 2 to the 3-inch range with medium-firm feel are ideal for back pain sufferers. 

On the other hand, those with shoulder pain, hip pain, or arthritis need softer toppers for enhanced cushioning. Mattress toppers 4 to 5 inches thick are a perfect alternative for persons with these medical conditions. That's because toppers this thick often have plusher layers that conform to the curves, relieving pressure points of your hips, shoulders, and joints. 

Do You Suffer from Allergies? 

Allergy sufferers will be better off with hypoallergenic mattress toppers. Some toppers, like natural latex or memory foam toppers are anti-bacterial and won't trigger allergies. On the other hand, other materials like feather or wool mattress toppers aren't hypoallergenic and can trigger your allergies during the night. 

Do You Sleep Alone or Share the Bed With a Partner?

Maybe you sleep just fine, but your partner is an active sleeper, and it's giving you sleepless nights. If you sleep with someone who sufferers from insomnia, a thick mattress topper can help offer that extra layer of comfort and support. 

Mattress Topper Types to Consider

There are many different types of mattress toppers in the market, and each comes with its own merits and demerits. The topper you need will depend on your firmness preference, sleeping position, body weight, and what you're looking for in a topper. 

Here's a list of some of the most popular and commonly used mattress toppers. 

Memory Foam Mattress Toppers

Memory Foam toppers are the most popular models thanks to their variety in viscosity and density. The material's unique property for body adaption makes the memory foam mattress topper a perfect pick for individuals with sore joints, arthritis, or back pain. 

These toppers provide comfort and significant body support, not to mention, have excellent durability. They also minimize motion transfer, making them great for couples and those who sleep with their pets.

A downside to most memory foam toppers is that they tend to retain body heat hence can lead to night sweats. Fortunately, with the different types of memory foam toppers in the market, you can find one that suits your sleep needs:

Standard memory foam toppers: A standard memory mattress topper is a medium-firm option that conforms to the body. Besides covering slight mattress imperfections, it can add to a mattress' lifespan. 

Polyfoam toppers: Polyfoam mattress toppers differ from memory foam toppers as they lack the added chemicals that give memory foam mattress toppers their density. As a result, they have a lower density and will flatten more easily than other foam toppers. However, polyfoam toppers have more bounce than a typical memory foam topper and are the cheapest alternative. 

Egg-crate memory foam toppers: These mattress toppers have a unique convoluted design that provides support and offers body contouring and pressure point relief. Most of them feature premium memory foam and are more expensive than other foam alternatives. 

Cooling gel-infused memory foam toppers: These are great for hot sleepers as they feature a cooling gel to regulate your body temperature, giving you a cool and comfortable sleep. They also promote maximum air circulation, preventing them from absorbing sweat and producing mold. This helps prolong your topper's durability.

Latex Mattress Toppers

Many mattress companies usually extract natural latex from rubber trees and use it to manufacture mattresses and other bedding items like mattress toppers. Just like memory foam, latex toppers are good at providing comfort and incredible support but are more expensive. 

They boast a firm texture and are often used to firm soft mattresses. Natural latex mattress toppers are well-known for their breathability, which allows for even airflow circulation. They're also hypoallergenic, durable, and effective at eliminating motion transfer. 

Alternatively, you can opt for synthetic latex toppers, which are made of synthetic rubber-like petroleum compounds. These models are less expensive than natural latex toppers, so if you're searching for an eco-friendly alternative, ensure the label says natural latex. 

Wool Mattress Topper

Natural wool toppers are rare to find, and that's why they're a bit expensive compared to other toppers. They have natural materials that offer unique temperature control, making them a perfect option throughout the year. 

During summer, it promotes airflow keeping you cool while sleeping, but during winter, it has high body heat retention and will keep you warm during the night. However, since wool is a natural material that lacks any added chemicals, it comes with a sheep-like odor that can last for a week or two when unpacked. 

Down and Down Alternative Mattress Toppers

Down is another topper that's not vegan. However, you can ensure your down mattress topper is responsibly sourced by looking for the Responsible Down Standard (RDS) label when shopping for your bedding. 

And if you'd like to steer clear of down altogether, a down alternative can work best for you. These toppers are usually filled with synthetic materials, such as rayon or polyester, but you can also find wool, cotton, and silk down alternatives. 

Why Is Mattress Topper Thickness Important?

The importance of choosing the right thickness level for your mattress topper lies in its comforting power. You'll feel the bed frame underneath you if your sleep surface is too thin, and if you're using an innerspring mattress, you'll feel the springs poking all over your body. 

That's why it's crucial to pay close attention to the thickness of the mattress topper you want to buy. Here are other reasons the thickness aspect of mattress toppers is essential. 

It Can Regulate Body Heat

Generally, toppers 2-3 inches thick usually promote proper breathability of the sleep surface and help regulate body temperature.  This makes them ideal for hot sleepers and individuals who sweat excessively. 

It Can Prevent Back Pain 

Depending on your needs, the right mattress topper can offer back pain relief. For instance, medium to medium-firm 4-inch mattress toppers can promote proper spinal alignment and provide pressure relief and spinal support. This is crucial to individuals with back conditions like scoliosis, lumbar pain, or sciatica. 

It Can Help with Medical Needs

A medium-firm to firm thicker mattress topper can offer additional support for persons with medical issues regarding their back, spine, or overall sleep positions. Such mattress toppers can also help with spinal misalignments, allergies, and other medical concerns. 

It Can Improve Sleep Quality 

When purchasing a mattress topper of the right thickness, you can improve your sleep quality significantly. Perhaps your mattress isn't supportive or comfortable enough, which can result in frequent awakenings due to sleep disturbances. A mattress topper with the right thickness can prevent all these by improving the functionality of your bed and providing the necessary comfort and support. 

Choosing the Best Topper for Your Needs

As you can see, there are various mattress topper thickness options available to help you customize your sleeping environment. While no single type of mattress topper can meet every sleeper's needs, there are vital factors you can weigh when deciding which thickness option to buy. 

What you settle for majorly depends on your unique needs, including your desire for a sustainable product and your budget.  You'll also want to consider any physical conditions like chronic pain or pregnancy. Rather than just focusing on the thickness of your mattress topper, consider your priorities to set yourself up for a more sound sleep.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *