Organic Mattress Topper Buying Guide

Last Updated: November, 2020 | This Post May Contain Affiliate Links

Most people think that you need to get a new mattress if you want to improve your sleep. Luckily, that misconception is just plain wrong. A good mattress topper can make a huge difference in how well you sleep, without the need to spend a bunch of money on a new mattress.

Organic mattress toppers are a healthy, eco-friendly addition to your mattress that’s designed to help bring extra comfort while you sleep. 

We've tested a handful of organic mattress toppers. In this guide, we'll break down everything we learned while testing, and recommend a handful of products that are worth your money.

According to our tests, the best organic mattress topper is the Plush Beds Natural Luxury Wool Topper. It's plush yet supportive and free of chemicals. It feels luxurious and is a great alternative to foam or latex.

5 Best Organic Mattress Toppers

PlushBeds Natural Luxury Wool Topper Small

PlushBeds Natural Luxury Wool Topper

5.0

This PlushBeds mattress topper is third party tested to ensure it's free of chemicals. It's wool that feels like a five-star luxury.

PlushBeds-Natural-Latex-Topper- small

Plush Beds Natural Latex Topper

5.0

This natural latex mattress topper is comfortable and has a loyal fanbase of customers who adore it for its cooling features and overall comfort. There's an option for whichever position you sleep in too. 

Sleep EZ Natural Latex Topper Small

Sleep EZ Natural Latex Topper

5.0

The Sleep EZ mattress toppers are natural, but they're also affordable. They're ideal for people that suffer from back pain and are on a tighter budget.

PureGreen Latex Mattress Topper Small

PureGreen 100% Organic Latex Mattress Topper

4.5

This PureGreen mattress topper is like an instant upgrade for your bed and can easily soften an overly firm mattress.

Naturally Nestled Soft Latex Mattress Topper Small

Naturally Nestled Mattress Topper

4.5

 If you like variety and choice, you'll love this natural mattress topper. You can choose the firmness and thickness that fits for you. 

PlushBeds Natural Luxury Wool Topper

Pros

  • Helps regulate temperature, great for hot sleepers
  • Extremely high-quality, handcrafted construction
  • Has just enough cradling feeling without sinking

Cons

  • Quite heavy, and can be difficult to remove to wash

Summary

There are plenty of reasons to choose wool for your bedding. One of the most obvious reasons being how comfortable it can be. While a lot of people think wool might get too hot, that's not always the case. This mattress topper is the perfect balance of the comfort and softness that wool provides, with construction that helps keep you cool by regulating your body temperature. 

Hot sleepers get another benefit with this natural wool mattress topper too. The material naturally wicks away sweat and moisture, which helps keep you cool and comfortable. 
We love how it works like a normal mattress topper, but doesn't really feel like one. We'd recommend this PlushBeds mattress topper for anyone that likes the idea of memory foam but doesn't like the typical sinking feeling or the heat it can trap. It still gives you a slight hugging feeling, but it doesn't make you feel trapped.

Everything about this mattress is natural, toxin-free, and totally safe for everyone in the family. Even the wool comes from a certified organic mill. PlushBeds even has their mattress toppers tested by a trusted third party, so you can feel safe and secure, knowing there aren't any harmful chemical residues where you're sleeping. 

If you're looking for an eco-friendly, luxury option to upgrade your bed, then this mattress topper deserves consideration. 

PlushBeds-Natural-Latex-Topper

Pros

  • Latex material and thousands of ventilation holes keep it very cool
  • Helps reduce back pain and keep the spine aligned
  • Extremely durable, can last for at least 20+ years

Cons

  • Stay away if you have a latex allergy

Summary

Natural latex is one of the newer mattress and mattress topper materials, but it's quickly becoming a favorite, and this one is one of the best latex mattress toppers out there. It helps relieve back pain, soothe pressure points, and helps prevent motion transfer across your mattress. I personally like most latex mattress materials because they provide plenty of support without sacrificing comfort or softness.

I tend to like a bed with a little bit of that body contouring that memory foam has, but not too much. This Plush Beds latex mattress topper provides just that. There's just a tiny bit of bounce, which keeps you from feeling like you're sinking but also makes it easier to get up and out of bed. If you suffer from back pain, like so many of us, this latex topper provides the perfect balance of contouring and back support to help keep your spine aligned. 

One of the best reasons, outside of the support and comfort, to give this mattress topper a try is how cool it stays. For extremely hot sleepers, even the mattresses designed to keep you coolest might not be enough. However, this topper impressed us with its cooling abilities. The latex naturally stays cool and dissipates body heat, but the ventilation also plays a big role in reducing heat retention. Within the latex, there are thousands of tiny ventilation holes that keep the air flowing and keep you cool and comfortable. 

If that's not enough, there's another huge bonus. The latex is a special Talalay latex, known for its quality and durability. In fact, you can count on it lasting for up to 20 years without losing structure or quality. 

Sleep EZ Natural Latex Topper

Pros

  • Made of all-natural latex, certified organic cotton, and wool
  • Very customizable, four different firmness options
  • You can choose different levels of firmness for each side

Cons

  • Not suited for people with latex allergies

Summary

Another great latex option from this list, the 2" latex comfort mattress topper from Sleep EZ is designed to keep you cool while providing added pressure relief and support to an existing mattress. 

When you choose Sleep EZ, you get more customizable options than just about any other mattress topper on this list. You can choose every part of the mattress topper, from the base material, size, thickness, firmness and whether or not you want to add a cover. 

Latex is known for providing a firmer support comfort layer. If you don't like the way, memory foam feels, trying a latex mattress topper can be a great alternative. This organic mattress topper is ideal for couples or singles who want to add more support to an existing mattress and need to customize their topper to be exactly what they want. 

PureGreen Latex Mattress Topper

Pros

  • Variety of options for both thickness and firmness
  • 100% natural latex and made with organic, natural materials certified by reputable organic organizations
  • Good quality at an affordable price point

Cons

  • Not for people with natural latex sensitivities or allergies

Summary

This is one of the best organic mattress toppers, and we have plenty of reasons why. First, we like that you can choose between three different thicknesses. The choices include one, two, or three inches. If you already have a somewhat soft mattress the one inch topper provides just enough support and cushion. Or, if you like a softer mattress and yours is too firm, you can choose a thicker topper, like the two or three inch options to soften it up as needed. 

That's not where your options stop, either. Thickness aside, you also have three different options for firmness: soft, medium, or firm. With this variety of options, it's hard not to find a 'Goldilocks' fit for your bed. 

There are no synthetic materials, just 100% natural latex. This latex mattress topper is made with such high standards, it's even certified by Oeko-Tex association, as well as the Eco Institute. 
If you're looking to refresh the way you sleep, and don't want to spend the money on a new mattress, these mattress toppers are the alternative you need. They're surprisingly affordable, and very well made, so you know they'll last the test of time. 

Naturally Nestled Soft Latex Mattress Topper

Pros

  • 100% natural latex, organic and vegan, certified by USDA, GOTS, OEKO-TEX, and GOLS
  • Naturally antimicrobial and repels dust mites (ideal for allergy sufferers)
  • Includes 100% certified organic cotton topper cover (removable for easy cleaning)

Cons

  • Hot sleepers might get too warm, the material seems to hold o

Summary

Some people like to take the natural, organic approach in their home a little bit further. We completely understand, and that's just one reason we had to include this Naturally Nestled mattress topper in our reviews. Not only is it made from entirely natural latex (no synthetic materials or fillers), but it's also 100% vegan. If that isn't enough, you don't have to take our word for it. It's GOTS certified and also earned certifications from GOLS, and even the USDA.

We love options, and between the two levels of thickness, and three levels of firmness, any type of sleeper is entirely covered. No matter what you choose, it's hard to beat the feeling this mattress topper gives you. If you're like us, you'll wake up wondering if you bought an entirely new mattress altogether. 

This Nestled mattress topper really uses the best qualities of natural latex to the fullest. You get all the support you need to keep your back comfortable and your spine aligned. However, it also doesn't sink, although it does give you a comfortable feeling that's somewhere between contouring and floating. 

What Is An Organic Topper for Mattress? 

Mattress toppers are great for when you need a fix for that old and uncomfortable mattress, but don't have the available funds to go out and purchase a new mattress at that time.

Mattress toppers add support, breathability and comfort to your current mattress, without breaking the bank. You simply place the topper on top of your mattress and put the fitted sheet on as you normally would and viola! Your mattress as that new feeling again with some added benefits.

Related Content:


Mattress toppers come in all shapes, sizes, firmness and materials. Organic materials will come from natural resources and are not chemically created by factories. For example, natural latex comes from the Hevea brasiliensis, or Rubber Trees. The sap from these trees is natural liquid latex and is tapped like sap from maple trees to make maple syrup- yummy.

In order to retain a label as "Organic" the materials must be processed without added synthetic materials or chemicals. Much like how organic beef has never had steroid or hormone shots, or man-made pesticides in its diet as it grew up.

What is an Organic Topper Made Of?

In most cases a organic mattress topper is made from a combination of natural and organic materials such as natural latex, certified organic cotton and wool. Each one has a specific purpose and use in the composition of a mattress topper.

  • Natural Latex Mattress Topper: This will be the layer giving the topper firmer support with added flexibility to conform to your body as you sleep.
  • Organic Cotton Topper: This is usually the cover for the topper that holds everything in place while still being very breathable and soft to the touch.
  • Organic Wool Mattress Topper: This is added for extra comfort, is naturally flame retardant and breathable. It makes the topper thicker, which makes you more comfortable.

If you're looking for a vegan mattress topper, there are some out there that are made with only 100% certified organic cotton cover and no wool or latex. 

Benefits of Using an Organic Topper

The best organic mattress toppers have many benefits, and it's not just about your own health either. The materials are chemical-free, so you won't get sudden rashes or allergic reactions. They are made from sustainable materials, and emit almost no pollution during production.

Naturally Sourced Materials

The materials are naturally sourced, and sustainably farmed rather than procured from other unstable or fluctuating sources. 

With rubber trees, they plant new trees whenever they cut down older trees, keeping the supply fresh, sustainable and stable so they don't have to tap into other resources to produce the natural latex.

Organic cotton and wool have similar processes, but go a bit farther in terms of sustainability. There are organic farms that raise sheep for wool and farms that grow organic cotton, and when the manufacturers purchase their product, it supports these businesses in the process. This maintains an ecosystem of its own in the process of generating organic and natural resources for mattress toppers.

No Unnecessary Chemicals

Organic mattress toppers are more naturally sourced and they don't add to the pollution most factories generate when developing synthetic materials. Additionally, they are generally healthier for you in the terms of your exposure to chemical agents.

A big benefit of having a natural and organic mattress topper, or organic anything really, is that you won't be bombarded by the smell that comes with synthetic or chemical infused substances. You will in turn not be affected by those chemicals.

Healthier for your body

Since no chemicals or additives are mixed into the materials, you prevent yourself from the unnecessary exposure to those chemicals which can be harmful to you and can even cause allergies to develop over time.

The factories produce less pollution, and because there's no added chemicals, there's no off-gas being pumped into the air from the toppers when you bring them home. This means you can breathe easier while you sleep. You'll feel rested and refreshed without having to breathe in nasty chemicals being released into the air over time.

More Breathable than Synthetic

Since organic cotton and wool are already very breathable, the combination helps to keep airflow within the organic mattress toppers, meaning hot air gets pulled away, allowing you to stay cooler while you sleep. 

Some synthetic materials don't allow as much airflow as natural fibers like wool and organic cotton fabric, which can lead to feeling hot and sweaty while laying in bed. Using an organic bed topper will elevate you just enough to get that airflow to wick away hot air from your body and keep you from waking up hot drenched in sweat.

Factors to Keep in Mind When Buying

There's a few things to keep in mind when looking for an organic mattress topper.

GOTS certified organic: Any product that is truly organic will have a certification like this one. GOTS certified organic, or Global Organic Textile Standard, is one to look for when it comes to organic textiles.

GOLS certified: This certification is for natural latex products. Any product that is labeled organic, but does not have either of these certifications is not truly organic.

Other Certifications for Organic Products

  • Fair-Trade Organic
  • Greenguard Gold
  • OEKO-TEX 100 Standard
  • USDA Organic (for organic cotton, wool, and latex)
  • eco-INSTITUT
  • Control Union
  • Forest Stewardship Council
  • CertiPUR0US (for foam)
  • Eco friendly


Pricing: While organic materials are safer and healthier for you, it does come with a higher price tag than synthetic made items. However, with an organic mattress topper, you'll find the investment to be worthwhile for all its health benefits and more.

Firmness: Most companies offer two levels of comfort with their organic mattress toppers- plush (super soft) and firm.

Materials: The material that your mattress topper is made of can affect your overall comfort level. If you emphasize a lot on spinal alignment and support, go for a memory foam mattress topper or an organic latex (talalay latex or dunlop latex) one as they tend to conform to your body better and offer more pressure relief. Wool offers less support but is quite cool to sleep on. You should also consider an organic cotton cover if you plan on having a cover for your mattress.

Density: If you want more support on the edges, pick a mattress topper with higher density memory foam. However, do note that high density foam types can make you feel warmer. If you want a softer feel, you could also consider a certified cotton mattress cover.

Durability: Organic mattress toppers are an investment that you'd want to last through the years. Hence, you should consider the average durability of the type you pick. In general, memory foam, latex and wool are well loved for being quite durable. They don't tend to sag even after years of usage. However, bear in mind that fiber or feather ones aren't usually as tough or hardy.

Is a Mattress Topper Washable?

This really depends on the organic mattress topper brand and composition of the topper. Some mattress toppers will have a removable cover that can be machine washed, but will need to be air dried to avoid damaging the cover and causing shrinkage. Be sure to read the care instructions carefully to keep your new mattress topper going for as long as possible.

Closing Thoughts

If you're looking to get the best organic, eco friendly mattress topper to add to your bed then you're headed in a great direction. Choosing organic over chemical-infused synthetics is healthier for you and for the planet- so you're saving two birds with one mattress topper!

While the search might be a touch arduous, it will be well worth it to finally get some of the best rest in your life.

Organic mattress toppers are made with only high-quality, and certified organic materials. This makes it healthier for you and for the planet by removing the need for harsh chemicals and additives that pollute the air and surrounding areas.

Many mattress stores will offer mattress toppers, so seeing them in person can help you get an idea of what you need and want in a topper that's organic and eco friendly.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *