Skip to content

Puffy Mattress Topper Review

Last Updated: June, 2024 | This Post May Contain Affiliate Links

Yes, you can buy a whole new mattress when you find that yours is too firm or soft, but there's an easier solution: a mattress topper. More specifically, the Puffy Mattress Topper. The Puffy Mattress Topper is made to add softness or firmness depending on your preferences, and for a price that doesn't break the bank. This responsive memory foam Puffy mattress topper might be just what you need to enjoy superior sleep, and wake up feeling ‘super human.’

While Purple is a big competitor in manufacturing top-quality bed products, it's yet to announce the release of its mattress topper. Luckily, Puffy has got you covered, with its world-class mattress toppers. If you want to find out more about our experience after testing out this Puffy Mattress topper, keep reading.

Puffy Mattress Topper Overview

Puffy Mattress Topper

Topper type:
Memory foam

3, 7

Trial length:
101 nights

twin, twin xl, full, queen, king, Cal king

Lifetime warranty

Who it’s best for:
Hot sleepers, back sleepers, side sleepers

The Puffy mattress topper is made of bamboo, polyester, and memory foam. This makes the mattress topper hypoallergenic since it also keeps out any bacteria or dust mites over time. When we tested how it felt to lay down on the quality mattresses, they felt firmer than other options. But they gradually soften as the mattress lifespan trickles down.

There’s a cover included with the Puffy mattress topper to add to your existing mattress as well, a lightweight cover that helps the Puffy mattress topper breathe during the night and that’s easy to remove and wash. This keeps you cool during the entire night, and with the anti-slip grip along the bottom, you won’t wake up with the Puffy mattress topper slipping off the bed in the morning either. 

Hot sleepers looking for a pocket-friendly way to prevent body heat retention should opt for gel-infused foam models like the Lucid Mattress Topper.


  • Includes the option of a 101-day sleeper trial, so it's completely risk-free for you to give it a try
  • You have a lifetime warranty for the Puffy mattress topper
  • The level of comfort means that side sleepers, stomach sleepers, and back sleepers can rest comfortably. Whether it's the right cushioned comfort for stomach sleepers or adequate pressure relief for side sleepers, the Puffy mattress topper is versatile and truly delivers for any sleeping style.
  • Includes deep elastic pockets (15-inch), meaning that it will fit on any mattress whether you have a memory foam, innerspring, hybrid or latex mattress 
  • The coolness of mattress topper the puffy is pretty much unparalleled. It's not only cool to touch, but you even feel a sense of coolness whenever you move.
  • Doubles as a mattress protector
  • Machine washable (read instructions)


  • The Puffy mattress topper is heavy, so it can be difficult to maneuver to get it clean
  • It's not a firm topper, so if that's what you're looking for, try a natural latex topper instead of this plush topper

Construction and Materials of The Puffy Mattress Topper

As soon as you get your Puffy Mattress Topper, you’ll want to get it out of the box to give it some time to decompress and air out. This is something that happens with any mattress toppers that come in a box like this. Unlike other mattress toppers and memory-foam mattresses though, this mattress topper does not have a chemical smell to it since it’s made of hypoallergenic materials—with no dangerous chemicals used in its construction.

The Puffy mattress Topper is only 2 inches thick so that you don't end up too high on your old mattress, and it comprises 40 percent bamboo and 60 percent polyester. It's made of oeko-tex certified materials, meaning that there are no chemicals involved.

Puffy Mattress Topper Thickness

With the Puffy mattress topper, you get to enjoy and lay on CertiPUR-US certified memory foam. The density depends on whether you want the soft or the firm mattress option. Regardless, the foam is well designed to keep you cool. This is thanks to the breathable cover, which lets air circulate through the topper and the entire mattress as you move around. The cover is machine washable so you can remove and wash it whenever you want to.

Keep in mind that this mattress topper’s removable and washable cover is naturally hypoallergenic, thanks to the bamboo rayon material, which is popularly known to be dust, mildew, mold, and mite resistant. Overall, the hypoallergenic materials make this Puffy Memory Foam Mattress Topper ideal for individuals with sensitivities to common allergens.

When it comes to this mattress topper's construction, we loved the deep elastic pockets. These durable elastic pockets are 15 inches deep, which means that you can use this topper with thicker mattresses. Even if you already have a 15-inch mattress, you'll be able to use this topper with it.

It's great to know that no matter the size of your old mattress, whether queen, twin XL, king, or any other size, the Puffy Mattress Topper will never slip off while sleeping. Just remember to pick a topper size compatible with your current mattress’ dimensions—for instance, a twin XL for a twin XL size bed. The thin grip base along the bottom of the Puffy mattress topper prevents it from sliding while you're sleeping. Unlike other toppers, this firmer sleeping surface includes mattress protectors to keep the mattress topper in place and protect the sides of your mattress.

Related Content: How to store a mattress topper

Comfort and Firmness

As mentioned, you get to choose your firmness level with the Puffy Mattress Topper. If you do pick the firmer mattress topper option, while it may start out quite firm, we did notice that it does soften up slightly over time, this is great if you have a firm mattress and want to add softness to it. Regardless of if you want a soft mattress or firm one, this topper can help.

Remember, though, that the feeling of your firmness will depend on the mattress you have underneath. If your mattress underneath is struggling, even the best Puffy mattress topper won't be able to save your mattress. If you have a firm mattress and want to change the feel completely, a mattress topper can improve the situation. But it won't solve all your problems.

The whole point of a new mattress topper is to change the comfort level of your bed, which is exactly what this Puffy mattress topper does. If you place it atop a soft or firm mattress, it will make you feel as though you’re sleeping on something medium-firm. Your new mattress topper has to be as firm or as soft as you prefer.

Regardless of the option you pick, we found both the firm and the soft mattress topper versions extremely comfortable for a good night's rest. Overall, the classic memory foam feel design ensured an extra cushioning feel around the shoulders and hips and effectively took the pressure off of our pressure points. You basically wake up the following day feeling relaxed, fresh as new, and rejuvenated. 

That’s due to the responsiveness of the memory foam, which will stay responsive regardless of your sleeping position or if you tend to move a lot throughout the night.

Speaking of comfort, it’s worth mentioning the motion transfer in this mattress too. Thanks to the foam construction, there’s a very minimal amount of motion transfer. If you move a lot when you sleep or if you have a partner who does, it’s easier to sleep comfortably with them.

A traditional foam mattress topper typically has a heat retention problem, causing discomfort through the night. Thankfully, Puffy mattress toppers are designed with naturally cooling materials that assure hot sleepers of a magnificent cooling effect that will keep their body heat in check and keep them comfortable all night long. This is on account of the breathable cover that allows air to circulate through it while they move and while they sleep

Related Content: Sleepez Topper Review

Different sleeping positions on Puffy Mattress Topper

When looking for the best foam mattress topper with all the bells and whistles that guarantee an enhanced sleep experience, such as the Molecule Topper or this Puffy model, your preferred sleeping position is a crucial consideration. This part of the Puffy Mattress Topper review will show you how this topper model influences overall sleep comfort in different sleeping positions.

Side Sleepers

Side sleepers will like how this Puffy Memory Foam Topper contours closely to the body curves, especially around the shoulders and hips. In fact, it ensures the neck, shoulders, and hips are properly aligned to relieve stress from your spine. This helps reduce the risks of waking up with back aches. Given its thick profile, this puffy Memory Foam Topper is ideal for lightweight side sleepers and some average-weight individuals under this category needing extra support. 

Back Sleepers

Generally, back sleepers need extra support around the lumbar region, which is essential for proper and healthy spinal alignment. Luckily, this Puffy Topper has a premium memory foam build engineered to conform excellently to your body, relieving painful pressure points while keeping your spine aligned properly. Lightweight sleepers falling under this category of sleepers—needing a firm bed—should consider pairing up their current mattresses with this Puffy topper. 

Stomach Sleepers 

Though not recommended by most sleep specialists, some individuals find stomach sleeping comfortable. With its medium firm feel, stomach sleepers can rest assured that this Puffy Mattress Topper will grant them the necessary premium support for alleviating back pain associated with spinal misalignment. This is because, like back sleepers, it offers stomach sleepers unparalleled support around the lumbar region, ideal for enhancing overall sleep comfort. Note that only lightweight sleepers in this category stand to benefit significantly from the topper. If you're a heavyweight stomach sleeper, you may want to opt for a firmer mattress topper.

Puffy mattress topper cover

Related Content: Dormeo Mattress Topper Review

Price, Warranty, Shipping, and Returns

It’s a good thing that this Puffy mattress topper clocks in at a reasonable price, especially when you realize how good the materials are, along with the fact that it suits any sleeping position, similar to their widely popular Puffy Lux mattress.

How much you spend on these best mattress toppers will depend on their firmness and size: the lowest price point is for the twin size. The price will increase with size, but you'll still be spending the same amount whether you pick the firm or the soft topper option.

This is a solid mid-level price point that isn't unreasonably priced at all, considering that it has two inches of memory foam to support you. And if you find that this topper isn’t working for you once you buy it, you have a 101-night sleep trial to back you.

Do keep in mind though that this trial is only in effect if you bought the topper right from Puffy. If you bought it from a thirty-party website like Amazon, you do not have the guaranteed sleep trial.

Speaking of shipping, if you do need to ship this mattress topper back, you will be able to ship it back with a money-back guarantee. While we often refund our clients’ original shipping costs, if you live in certain areas like Alaska, Hawaii, or Canada, the refund won’t be possible. We don’t refund original shipping costs from these areas.

When we were waiting for our Puffy topper delivery, it didn't take a lot of processing time. It took only a little while to get a shipping notification—and just 2-5 days from there for our mattress to arrive at our doorstep.

You won’t be charged shipping for the Puffy topper unless you live in Alaska, Hawaii, or Canada, but you should probably make sure that you’re at home when your topper arrives. Like other in-a-box toppers or mattress options, it will arrive compressed and left at your door; you just need to let it air out for a little while before you put it up on your bed.

The Puffy mattress topper gives you a lifetime warranty to put your mind at ease. That means that if you see any defects, you can return them for a full refund. Just keep in mind that any damage from commercial usage or abuse is not covered under the warranty. If you stain it, this is not covered either. It covers mainly defects that occur at the manufacturing stage of the puffy toppers.

Who are the Puffy Mattress Toppers Suited For?

Puffy mattress memory foam toppers are perfect for anyone who wants to:

  • Have a cooling sleep through the night - Enjoy the cooling sensation that these support mattresses offer when you lay on them - their breathable covers allow air to circulate freely thus creating a cool and comfy surface. The polyester and bamboo materials used to make the avocado mattress topper also keep the topper from retaining excessive body heat.
  • Change the firmness of their mattress without spending too much - It's literally like enjoying a brand new mattress, without spending an exorbitant amount. Simply choose from Firm, medium firm or Soft topper to change your current mattress firmness to a level that you'd like.
  • Have a new layer over their current mattress - You might not want to change the firmness level of your existing mattress, but it might be time to veneer your old mattress with a fresh new layer after all those years of use that have caused fading and wear and tear.


Where Can I Buy the Puffy Mattress Topper?

You can buy any Puffy foam mattress topper from a third-party website like Amazon, but it's best for you to make your purchase from the Puffy store. This is only because if you buy from the Puffy mattress online store, you’ll get that 101-night sleep trial on this memory foam mattress topper, which you won’t get otherwise.

What if I Don’t Like It?

You already know that you have a 101-night sleep trial to decide if you want to keep it or return it, so if you don't like this Puffy topper, you have this option. But you do need to keep in mind that you have to use this topper for a minimum of 30 days before you can return it. You can't test it for a week and then ship it back; you have to have it for those 30 nights.

Do I Really Need a New Topper?

The whole point of getting yourself a mattress topper is to make your bed more comfortable, without spending the money that you would normally spend on a brand new mattress. You don’t need to buy a new mattress topper if you’re getting a new mattress already, and you don’t need a topper if you’re already satisfied with the feeling of your bed.

You’ll really want to pick a mattress topper if your mattress is too soft or too firm, since Puffy offers both firm and soft topper options. You can even buy one if you and your partner sleep differently—just use the Puffer mattress topper to even out the feeling of the mattress, or to help one partner sleep more comfortably

What is a Puffy Mattress Pad and How is it Different from the Puffy Topper?

Mattress pads serve a different purpose; mattress pads are meant to be an extra soft layer atop your mattress. It doesn't alter your mattress firmness. When it comes to the Puffy mattress pad, people like it for a more cushioned, luxurious feel.

If you want a soft surface that almost feels like a comfortable pillow, then consider a mattress pad.

On the other hand, a mattress topper has memory foam and is able to actually provide more support while adjusting your mattress firmness. In a way, it does more than an ordinary mattress topper and is able to help relieve pressure points too.

Closing Thoughts

Why spend so much money buying a new mattress when you can enjoy the same new feel and comfort (among numerous other benefits) at a lesser cost with the memory foam mattress toppers? With the Puffy Mattress Topper can enhance the comfort or firmness level you need, get to sleep in any position without compromising your skeletal-muscular integrity or comfort. These versatile toppers can be placed on any bed as you have the luxury of choosing the size and firmness degree that you desire. With this memory foam topper, you might find that a perfect night’s sleep is just one purchase away.

Other Reviews:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *